What comes to mind think of when you think of Neil Young? A pacifist folkie strumming away with Dylan and Mitchell, a hard rocking guitar hero, the Godfather of Grunge? Maybe you remember him for Trans…. Whichever it is, you wouldn’t think of Young as a lecherous old geezer; a hard drinking, womanising, troublemaker. Nonetheless this is the persona which Young assumes for his best song in years: Dirty Old Man, a pure slab of Crazy Horse wonder which out-shines all the other tracks on his latest album Chrome Dreams II.
Young’s been very prolific in recent years, especially considering his close brush with death due to a brain aneurysm in 2005. However all his recent albums have had a very conceptual basis. This began with Greendale back in 2003, his astonishingly good melodramatic hillbilly opera. Since then they all seem to have been experimental exercises in theme or genre. Prairie Wind was a hark back to Harvest era folkieness, Living with War was his attempt to reinstate the power of the protest song. Chrome Dreams II however is an entirely different kettle of ferrets. It’s a sequel to the unreleased original Chrome Dreams, which was planned but unfortunately shelved in 1977 in favour of American Stars and Bars. The original included Like a Hurricane, an acoustic version of Powderfinger, Welfare Mothers and Pocahontas to name just the very best. As a result, the title of this release is striking statement of Young’s belief in these songs.
It starts with a harmonica, some lilting guitar and suddenly we’re wondering whether Beautiful Bluebird is a cutting floor victim from Harvest. Is this 1972? The second track Boxcar gets things moving a bit, it’s got an Ohio vibe to it and ghostly backing vocals, nonetheless it still feels dated. This is because the first three tracks of Chrome Dreams II are all relics of the eighties from the This Note’s for You era. Ordinary People is the third of these, an eighteen minute long dirge of traditional Young verse/solo composition. Bombastic horn arrangements smother all the instrumental passages and even when we do get to hear a bit of Young’s guitar licks they seem tired and worn, with none of the fieriness of Cowgirl in the Sand or Cinnamon Girl. Although these have been live standards for years, they’ve never been recorded before, and in truth there’s no real need to air them now. Despite this Ordinary People has been a firm favourite in Young’s live repertoire for years. We were bound to see it released at some stage, though in this current form it’s only a chore to listen to.
The rest of the album is melange of new songs in different styles, but two themes thread all the tracks together: old-age and, Neil’s old favourite, the open road. Shining Light, The Way and The Believer all tie in the old-age theme in a slightly corny but soul-infused way. This is a style that Young has flirted with before but never fully embraced. The Way especially encapsulates this, with its very lo-fi Beatles-esque sound. It’s a wonder to hear Young trying something that for him sounds fresh. It’s a sweet sixties-pop gem. Whereas Spirit Road and No Hidden Path run the same gauntlet of hippie-rock nostalgia that he’s tread countless times before. Dirty Old Man is without a doubt the highlight of Chrome Dreams II. It rocks. Really hard. In the way you want Neil to rock; completely fuzzed out with lashings of blasted solos and that Crazy Horse pounding that sounds like the hooves of the great Lakota’s mount thundering across the plains. It’s also comic, try imagining Neil as filthy old man; drunk, sneering at women and starting fights he’s bound to lose. To top it off it has the haunting sense of melancholy that all his best songs contain, a sense that this may be a tragedy, but the feeling is too ambiguous for us to pin down.
Chrome Dreams II has been released at a time when many were expecting the release of the Archives box set they have been anticipating for years. An eight disc box set of live recordings, b-sides and rough cuts from Young’s long and meandering career seems like the perfect way to cap off the work one of popular music’s rock legends . This probably isn’t going to appear any time soon though. Young is like Madonna, constantly shifting, changing and looking for new creative outlets. Unlike the Harlot-Queen of Pop though, these aren’t motivated by any desire to conform to marketing department demands; he follows his own muse. Although in recent years she has led him astray, to create some boring and sometimes puzzling work; with Chrome Dreams II, Neil Young is back on track to creating not essential, and maybe not great, but certainly good and solid eclectic albums in the style of After the Goldrush. If he continues at this rate, don’t expect Archives anytime time soon. Mr. Young just remember; rust never sleeps.